Jane Eyre and White Knight syndrome

How some of the books I read in my youth set me up for a lifetime of bad choices.

Like Comment

I caught the Bronte bug early. The fascinating story of the three daughters of a  clergyman growing up in the wilds of Yorkshire, living lives constrained by gender and class and yet managing to conjure up such vast, richly imagined and boldly anarchic novels, helped to make their books utterly compelling. 

They also spoke to the lonely, troubled teenager in me. I may not have been experiencing the social and physical isolation shared by Emily, Anne and Charlotte, but I felt every bit as alone and misunderstood as my heroines. So, when Emily’s Cathy Earnshaw finds her destiny in the wild and cruelly possessive Heathcliff of Wuthering Heights, and Charlotte’s Jane Eyre returns to Thornfield to find Mr Rochester blinded, maimed and with his first wife conveniently dead, I relished the romantic tragedy of the first book and the “happy ending” of the second. 

A recent re-read of Jane Eyre encouraged me to reflect on the impact of these books on my younger self, and particularly on my expectations of romantic love. What did I find so attractive about the obsessive darkness of Heathcliff and the controlling, deceitful Rochester, who kept his first wife locked in the attic of his comfortable, capacious, country house, denying her existence to the extent that he almost got away with tricking the much younger and naïve Jane into a bigamous marriage? 

The Bronte sisters managed to make these troubled, violent and hard-drinking men so attractive that I can’t have been the only young woman who was blindsided into seeking completely the wrong qualities in potential boyfriends, and at risk of developing a full-blown case of what psychologists have called “White Knight”, or Rescuer Syndrome. 

More commonly attributed to men, (hence the White Knight moniker) rescuer syndrome describes the attraction to romantic partners perceived as needing to be saved, most often from themselves, perhaps because they have histories of abuse, trauma or addiction or have been otherwise damaged by life’s events. 

The would-be rescuer displays behaviour which goes beyond mere altruism, or the natural desire to help someone they care about. They invest time, energy and other resources into trying to solve their loved one’s problems and, on the face of it at least, will not seek much in return (except, of course, the love, praise and gratitude of the person being rescued). 

Jane Eyre is a classic rescuer. She falls in love with the brooding, bad-tempered and clearly troubled Rochester and becomes convinced of her own ability to offer redemptive love, with little expectation of being found worthy or deserving of reciprocity.  

My early romantic relationships were almost certainly marred by a desire to ‘rescue’, whether from the kind of commitment phobia many of the objects of my affections seemed to experience (“He’s been hurt before so I will take the emotional hardship on the chin and prove to him that I will stick by him no matter what”) or from something more serious (“I know he has a drink/drugs problem….if I love him enough I will be able to save him from himself”). In classic rescuer mode, I would set about trying to make these relationships work, often at the expense of my own needs and emotional wellbeing. 

If I had been encouraged to take a step outside of my own dramas and consider things from a different, more objective, perspective, I may have had healthier relationships and been better able to appreciate that I was not the main character in anyone’s story but my own, and not responsible for anyone else’s happiness either.

If you have a relative or friend who you suspect is caught in the position of ‘rescuer’, one of the first ways to help them get out of it is to encourage them to take this ‘sideways step’ and recognise the dynamics that are in play. Try asking them “What is your intention towards this person?” to unroot any White Knight tendencies. Another useful question to ask is “What would you tell your best friend, if she/he was in this position?”.

In common with many rescuers, I suspect that it was a lack of self-worth or confidence that lay at the root of my own well-meant, but ultimately misguided, attempts to ‘save’ people (generally men) from themselves. Developing strategies to work on these, one of which may be working with a coach to identify one’s own unique strengths and attributes, and to recognise and then reject negative and irrational aspects of our character, may help to avert future misguided missions.

Louise Rodgers

Founder & coach, eidyia ltd

The competing pressures of modern life can make it hard to keep a sense of who you are, what you want, and the steps you need to take in order to live your “best life”. I give the individuals and businesses I work with the opportunity to stand back and take stock. A skilled thinking partner to work with while you do this may be all you need in order to find clarity, a renewed sense of purpose and a good view of the road ahead. I call this process reflect, reframe and refocus and I do my best to make sure it is a fun, creative and thought-provoking journey of self-awareness. Before training as a coach with Barefoot, I co-founded and ran my own PR agency. I know what it’s like to build and lead a creative start-up, to juggle multiple projects and to find some balance between work, home and family life. I have found my niche in working with creative individuals and entrepreneurs from all backgrounds. Past clients have included one who runs a ninja training gym, another embarking on a new career as delicatessen owner and a third who now heads up a social enterprise business.